How to Decide Between Metal and Shingle Roofing
November 17, 2026

November 17, 2026

Choosing a new roof is one of the biggest decisions you'll make for your home. It affects how your house looks, how well it stands up to the weather, and how much you'll spend on upkeep for years to come. For many homeowners, the choice comes down to two popular options: metal roofing and asphalt shingles. Both have clear strengths, and the right pick depends on your budget, your home, and your long-term plans. Below, we'll walk through the key factors to help you decide which option is the best fit for you.


Comparing Upfront Costs

For many homeowners, cost is the first thing that comes to mind. Asphalt shingles usually have a lower upfront price, which makes them a popular choice for those working with a tighter budget or planning to sell in the near future. A metal roof typically costs more to install because of the materials and the specialized labor involved. The difference can vary depending on the size of your roof, the style of metal panels you choose, and how detailed the installation is. Looking only at the initial price, though, doesn't tell the whole story. It's important to consider how long each option will last and what it will cost to maintain over time.


Looking at Long-Term Value

When you consider the full life of your roof, the numbers can start to look different. According to HomeGuide, metal roofs provide a high return on investment and long-term savings because they improve energy efficiency and last two to three times longer than standard asphalt shingles. That means a single metal roof may outlast multiple shingle replacements over the same period of time. Fewer replacements can mean fewer disruptions, less waste, and lower costs in the long run. If you plan to stay in your home for many years, metal roofing can be a smart investment. Shingles can still offer good value, especially for homeowners focused on keeping upfront costs down.


Weighing Durability in Mountain Weather

Here in Western North Carolina, roofs face a little bit of everything, from heavy rain and summer storms to snow, ice, and strong winds on higher ground. Metal roofs are known for their strength and resistance to wind, and snow tends to slide off them more easily. They also don't crack, curl, or lose granules the way shingles can over time. Quality architectural shingles have improved a great deal and can handle most weather conditions well when properly installed. However, they may be more prone to wind damage, granule loss, and wear as they age. Thinking about your home's elevation, tree cover, and exposure to the elements can help guide your decision. Homes surrounded by tall trees may also see more falling limbs and debris, which is worth keeping in mind.


Considering Energy Efficiency

Your roof plays a role in how comfortable your home feels and how hard your heating and cooling systems need to work. Metal roofs reflect a large share of the sun's heat, which can help keep attic temperatures lower during hot summer months. That may lead to reduced cooling costs and a more comfortable home. Asphalt shingles tend to absorb more heat, although lighter colors and proper attic ventilation can help. Energy savings will vary depending on your home's insulation, ventilation, and roof color. Still, many homeowners appreciate the added efficiency that comes with metal roofing.


Thinking About Maintenance Needs

Every roof needs some care, but the amount of upkeep can vary. Shingle roofs may need occasional repairs for missing, cracked, or curling shingles, especially after storms. Over time, granule loss and aging materials can lead to leaks if problems aren't addressed. Metal roofs generally require less frequent maintenance, though fasteners, seams, and flashing should still be checked periodically. Standing seam metal roofs use concealed fasteners, which can help reduce maintenance concerns. Regular inspections are a good idea no matter which material you choose, since catching small issues early helps protect your home. For busy homeowners, the lower upkeep that comes with metal roofing can be a major selling point.


Matching Your Home's Style

Your roof has a big impact on your home's curb appeal. Asphalt shingles come in a wide range of colors and styles, including architectural shingles that add depth and dimension. They work well on traditional homes and blend easily into most neighborhoods. Metal roofs offer a clean, modern look, but they also suit farmhouses, cabins, and mountain homes beautifully. Standing seam panels create sleek vertical lines, and metal is available in many colors and finishes. Taking a look at homes in your area and thinking about the style you want can help you choose a roof that complements your property.


Considering Noise and Comfort

Some homeowners worry that a metal roof will be noisy during rainstorms. In reality, when a metal roof is installed over solid decking with proper underlayment and insulation, the sound inside the home is often similar to other roofing materials. Many people find the soft sound of rain on metal relaxing. Shingle roofs naturally absorb more sound, which some homeowners prefer. If noise is a concern, talking with your roofing team about installation methods can help put your mind at ease. Comfort inside your home has more to do with how the roof is installed than with the material alone.


Checking Your Roof's Pitch and Structure

The shape of your roof can also influence your decision. Asphalt shingles work best on roofs with a moderate to steep slope, since they rely on gravity to shed water. Standing seam metal roofs can perform well on a wider range of slopes, including some lower-pitched roofs where shingles may not be the best fit. Your roof decking and structure also need to be in good condition to support either option. A professional inspection can determine whether your roof is a good match for metal roofing or shingles. It can also reveal any repairs that should be made before installation begins.


Planning for How Long You'll Stay

How long you plan to live in your home is one of the most important factors in this decision. If you expect to move within a few years, a quality shingle roof may give you the best balance of cost and curb appeal. If you plan to stay for the long haul, the durability and lifespan of a metal roof may offer greater value over time. A new roof of either type can also be a selling point when it's time to put your home on the market. Thinking about your future plans helps you choose a roof that fits both your budget and your goals. There's no single right answer, only the best fit for your situation.


At Consolidated Roofing Contractors, Inc, we're a local, family-owned and veteran-owned company that has served Asheville and Western North Carolina since 2003. We install and repair both metal roofing, including standing seam systems, and asphalt shingle roofs for homes and businesses throughout Buncombe, Haywood, Henderson, and Madison Counties. Our team will walk you through warranty options for your chosen materials, help with insurance claims when needed, and provide free estimates within two to three days. We also offer emergency repairs and storm damage services. Contact Consolidated Roofing Contractors, Inc today to schedule your free estimate.

metal roofing
November 21, 2026
Understanding the benefits of metal roofing can help you determine whether this material is a good fit for your residential or commercial property.
local roofers
November 6, 2026
Learn what to expect during a professional roof inspection and how local roofers identify damage, recommend repairs, and protect your home.
roof repair company
November 5, 2026
In this article, we'll go over why choosing a roof repair company can protect your home. Be sure to give us a call today!
Show More →